What to Do if Your Car Keys Are Stolen [2025]

We’ve all locked ourselves out of our cars at one time or another, right? How do you get keys locked in a car? It’s a common predicament that can be both frustrating and inconvenient. Whether it’s due to a momentary lapse of memory or an accidental lockout, finding yourself on the wrong side of a locked car door happens to the best of us. However, there’s something even worse when it comes to cars and keys, something that most of us will never experience. That something is having our car keys stolen.

If this ever happens to you, try not to panic, because there are some fairly simple things you can do to protect yourself and regain your peace of mind.

If your car keys were stolen, it can be merely a minor inconvenience to some. To others, it can be a nightmare compounded by the fact that most of us carry our house keys on the same key ring.

If you keep our car’s registration or insurance card in the car, it then becomes possible for the thief to easily find out where we live. If the thief then has both your car and house keys, you become extremely vulnerable no matter where you are.

Entering your ZIP code in the box above gets you started on your way to finding competitive lost car key insurance rates online.

What should you do if you lose your car keys?

Losing your car keys is quite different than having them stolen. You should always call the police about stolen car keys. That way you can figure out who took them and put a stop to anything they may want to do.

Losing them can be frustrating, but maybe not as scary. Try to retrace your steps, but if they’re truly gone, check if car insurance covers lost key fobs. If not, you will want to visit the dealership so that they can program new keys.

The other option is to have your locks changed. You can deactivate the lost key fob to your car. To deactivate lost or stolen car key fobs, visit your car dealership. You can also purchase a new remote.

What about if my car keys were stolen from the car?

The first thing to do is immediately call the police as soon as you know your keys have been stolen. Worry about where they’re headed before concerning yourself with a stolen car key replacement.

Fill out a police report with as much detail as possible, including trying to think of anyone you know who might be motivated to steal your keys. Include as much information as you can, because every detail counts in a police investigation.

After you file the police report, the officer will probably advise you as to whether or not you need to take certain safety precautions.

From there you should call your car insurance company to see if you’re covered for replacement locks. If your keyring also contained your house keys, a call to your homeowner’s insurance company is also in order.

Both insurance companies may cover the cost of lock replacement, or they may not. But the only way you’ll know for sure is by contacting them and asking the question. If they do, at least that is some benefit.

Do you need to change your locks after your keys are lost or stolen?

Can key fobs be deactivated? If your car is a newer model with computer chips embedded in the car keys, you will probably not need to change the locks on your car door. Instead, you’ll be able to go to a local dealer who sells cars from the same manufacturer and have them reprogram a new key for you.

This is probably the cheapest way to go, although you still might be charged a few hundred dollars.

If your car is older, and programmable keys are not part of the equation, you’ll need your locks and your ignition changed.

As far as your house locks are concerned, whether or not you need to change them depends on several circumstances.

Home Security if House Keys Are Stolen With Car Keys

Regardless, changing your home locks is probably vastly more important than changing your car locks. With your home, your personal safety, as well as that of your family, is at risk.

Is there anything else you should do if your keys are lost or stolen?

The last thing you need to do if your car keys are stolen is to pay attention to suspicious people who might be hanging around. Even after your car locks have been changed, the thief may not be aware of that fact.

You may see someone suspicious in the neighborhood, or in a public parking lot, giving you plenty of reason to be anxious.

If you are nervous at any time, you should err on the side of caution and call the police.

You should also keep your eyes open for your keys just in case it turns out that you really misplaced them. If that ends up being the case, you’ll need to report that to the police as soon as possible. If you’re unable to find them, and you end up having to leave your vehicle alone, or items are stolen from your car before you realize your keys were taken, you’ll want to follow up with the police and your insurance.

Don’t worry, everyone makes mistakes. If you found your lost car keys, the police will not have an issue that they weren’t stolen after all.

The only way you’ll get in trouble is if you found your lost keys and failed to inform the police, causing them to continue a fruitless investigation.

It only takes a few minutes to see side-by-side car insurance quotes, so why not enter your ZIP code in the box below right now?

Read more: Does car insurance cover lost car keys?

Case Studies: What to do if your car keys are stolen?

Case Study 1: Immediate Police Report

Lisa’s car keys were stolen, and she immediately called the police to report the incident. She followed the necessary steps, including filing a detailed police report and contacting her car insurance company and homeowner’s insurance company. This case study emphasizes the importance of promptly notifying the authorities and insurance providers when car keys are stolen.

Case Study 2: Changing Locks and Ignition

Mark’s car keys were stolen, and his vehicle did not have programmable keys. As a result, he had to change the locks and ignition of his car to ensure security. This case study highlights the need to take appropriate measures, such as lock replacement, to protect against potential unauthorized access to the vehicle.

Case Study 3: Safeguarding Personal Safety

Emma’s car keys were stolen, and she was concerned about her personal safety since her house keys were also on the same key ring. She reported the incident to the police, changed her locks, and remained vigilant for any suspicious activity. This case study emphasizes the importance of prioritizing personal safety and taking necessary precautions after car key theft.